Council documents and notes on a sunlit table
Reports 7 pages · Council resource
Council resource

Underperforming Manager Scorecard

A printable council worksheet for deciding whether poor strata management service is serious enough to start a replacement search.

Quick answer

When should council start replacing an underperforming strata manager?

Council should start a replacement search when the service pattern is documented across communication, financial reporting, meeting preparation, follow-through, records, and owner response.

Use this before council puts a manager-change motion on the agenda.

The PDF includes:

  • 10 service dimensions to score from 1 to 5
  • an evidence column so the score is tied to records, not frustration
  • three recommendation bands
  • an evidence log for recurring service problems
  • an action ladder for staying, comparing, or preparing a replacement search
  • an improvement-request email template
  • escalation paths for manager, managing broker, BCFSA, and CRT issues
  • BC-specific source notes and research links

A council should not switch managers because one week was frustrating. It should switch when the pattern is clear enough to defend.